Product was very promptly shipped and arrived within three days. As noted in other reviews, the colors of the replacement cards are very close to the original. (They seem just a tad more saturated, but it is well within the margin of acceptability, and you will not notice the difference when playing.) The surrounding black border is slightly uneven. The cards are the same size and weight of the cards that came with the game.
I bought the second edition, so there were very few updates I needed to make to rulebook due to errata from the FAQ. I highly recommend purchasing the complete errata card set and am having a fantastic time playing this game, which would have been dimiished if I had to manually correct the cards.